Many people have a need to
label others. They struggle to ease the complexity of dealing with whole people
by mentally putting them in a labeled box of who they think they are. They see
someone for the first time and immediately begin to make judgments based on
ethnicity, language, gender, religion, and other labels.
In work situations, labels
can be particularly dangerous. A former school principal, I am aware that the
most important influence for learning in any classroom is teacher expectations.
The potential for doing damage to children is quite real when they are labeled
negatively. Labels in the
healthcare professions can also be damaging. Consider this research about
perceptions resulting from labeling residents with dementia.
This study examined the
labeling of nursing home and hospice residents, how it influenced employees’
perceptions, and how those perceptions could affect resident-caregiver
interactions. Forty-three employees in various staff positions from a rural
hospice and an urban nursing home were involved. Participants read a vignette
based on a fictional resident’s behavior. They rated their perceptions of the
behavior, indicating if and how they would report the event, and made
recommendations for a possible course of action. Although the vignettes were
the same, the fictional resident was labeled either as an Alzheimer’s resident
in a specialized care unit or as a resident of a non-specialized long-term care
unit.
Can you guess the results? If
you guessed that the behavior of the resident labeled as an Alzheimer’s
resident was perceived to be more problematic, inappropriate, and aggressive
than the same behavior of the resident without the Alzheimer’s label, you would
be right. Perceptions regarding a resident having Alzheimer’s disease were
negative. Labels that interfere with impartial thinking of healthcare workers
and others can be harmful to residents’ quality of life. The purpose of this
post is to emphasize the importance of viewing people with dementia or any
other disease as people first and not as disease labels.
In this video titled Live Outside
the Stigma, Dr. Richard Taylor
explains his personal life experiences and consequences of living with the
myths and stigmas of dementia, probably the Alzheimer’s type.
Frances Shani Parker,
Author
Becoming Dead Right: A
Hospice Volunteer in Urban Nursing Homes
is available in paperback at many booksellers and in e-book form at
Amazon and Barnes and Noble booksellers.